In the 5th century BC, the sophists emerged amid a cultural transformation in Greece, marked by intellectual flourishing in Athens. Similar to the Enlightenment, this period favored rational and pragmatic approaches, rejecting superstitions. The sophists became central figures, offering sophisticated education that combined rhetoric, philosophy, and emerging sciences, primarily for the Athenian elite.
The word "sophist" derives from sophos, meaning "wise," and shares the same root as philosophy (love of wisdom). Originally, the term had no pejorative connotation. However, criticisms from philosophers like Plato and Aristotle attributed a negative image to the sophists, portraying them as masters of manipulation, capable of making falsehoods appear true. This distorted view persisted until the 19th century, when sophists were often considered "professional deceivers."
Itinerant masters like Protagoras, Gorgias, and Hippias traveled throughout Greece, offering paid instruction. Their classes focused on the art of persuasion, preparing students for public debates and legal disputes—crucial skills in Athenian democracy. They reinterpreted the concept of arete (excellence or virtue) as an adaptable practical skill, contrasting with philosophers like Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, who sought universal truths.
With Athens' transition from an aristocratic society to a democracy, active participation in public life became a fundamental requirement. The new arete, or excellence, was no longer limited to aristocratic values but included civic skills essential for democratic citizens. Individuals needed to be capable of expressing themselves well, articulating their ideas, and arguing persuasively in the Agora, the political and social center of the city.
The sophists met this need by teaching rhetoric and oratory, considered the arts of speaking and persuading. As itinerant teachers, they traveled from city to city offering their lessons to those who could afford them. With their eloquence, they demonstrated their skills in public, showing themselves capable of manipulating words and persuading their interlocutors. Their main function was to prepare young people to actively participate in political life and win public debates, an essential attribute in Athenian direct democracy.
Sophist Education: Rhetoric and Relativism
The sophists are recognized as history's first professional teachers, playing a crucial role in shaping Athenian citizenship during the democratic era. Beyond teaching discourse techniques, they transmitted comprehensive knowledge about politics, ethics, and general culture, preparing competent citizens for the democratic context. This educational approach was particularly valued by families of emerging classes, such as merchants and artisans, who saw rhetoric as an essential tool for political advancement.
However, the practice of charging for their teachings generated severe criticism, especially from Socrates and Plato. These philosophers accused the sophists of turning knowledge into a commodity, deviating from an ethical commitment to truth. Despite the criticisms, the sophists consolidated the importance of logical argumentation and persuasive discourse—skills that shaped civic life in ancient Greece and remain influential in modern education.
The sophists are also considered the founders of liberal education in the West, introducing to the curriculum the disciplines that later became known as the seven liberal arts. Divided into trivium (Grammar, Dialectic, and Rhetoric) and quadrivium (Arithmetic, Geometry, Astronomy, and Music), these disciplines formed the basis of a comprehensive education. The sophist educational approach was not limited to specific techniques, such as legislation or political economy, but aimed to form complete personalities, promoting a holistic understanding of the knowledge of the time.
Furthermore, the sophists implemented pedagogical methods that influenced contemporary university teaching. Their courses were based on lectures, discussions of predetermined or improvised topics, and the reading and analysis of poetic texts. This method fostered critical thinking and argumentative ability, essential skills for active participation in Athenian democracy. Sophistry, as an educational movement (paideia), emphasized the importance of mastering both favorable and opposing arguments on any topic, preparing students to win debates in various circumstances.
The sophists advocated moral and epistemological relativism, arguing that truth is subjective and depends on cultural and individual context. Protagoras of Abdera, for example, stated that "man is the measure of all things," emphasizing the subjectivity of human experience. Gorgias of Leontini, another prominent sophist, explored persuasion as a powerful tool, going so far as to argue that even the non-existent can be defended as existent. This relativism challenged traditional conceptions of truth and morality, promoting the idea that norms, laws, and customs are human conventions subject to change through dialogue and consensus.
The sophists also introduced the concept of paideia, expanding it from simple childhood education to comprehensive cultural formation. This notion recognizes education as a continuous process of personal development, without temporal limits, as long as there is interest in learning and self-improvement. They considered human nature educable and malleable, but not totally manipulable, highlighting the importance of the pedagogical triad: nature, knowledge, and exercise. This triad, later theorized by Plutarch and adopted by classical and humanist-renaissance tradition, emphasizes that education must balance innate dispositions with appropriate learning and practice.
Despite criticisms, notably from Plato, the sophists played a crucial role in democratizing political discourse and valuing public debate. Their contributions to relativism and rhetoric profoundly influenced Western thought, promoting argumentation and persuasion skills that remain relevant today. Figures like Protagoras and Gorgias stood out by challenging traditional concepts, fostering a dynamic and pluralistic intellectual environment in ancient Greece.
Famous Sophists
Protagoras, one of the most renowned sophists, distinguished himself through his humanistic approach and emphasis on education and rhetoric. Born in Abdera, his trajectory was remarkable: from humble origins, he became an influential thinker in Athens, accumulating wealth and cultivating friendships with leaders like Pericles. His agnosticism, expressed in the fragment "On the Gods", maintained that knowledge about deities was limited, rejecting both religious fanaticism and atheism.
The famous phrase "Man is the measure of all things" synthesizes Protagoras's relativism and humanism, suggesting that truth is subjective and depends on individual perception. He rejected absolute standards in ethics, religion, and politics, asserting that human institutions are products of an ever-changing civilization. This view promoted freedom of thought and challenged the imposition of dogmas, consolidating his role as an advocate for a dynamic and pluralistic society.
As an educator, Protagoras saw education as an essential tool for human intellectual development. He maintained that civic virtues could be taught and viewed punishment not as revenge, but as a means of improvement. His philosophy, marked by optimism about human potential, remains relevant, inspiring reflections on ethics, freedom, and progress in today's society.
Other Sophists
The sophists, influential thinkers in ancient Greece, challenged conventions and explored themes such as ethics, politics, and language. Their legacy continues to influence contemporary debates about morality, power, and communication.
- Thrasymachus and Callicles questioned the foundations of justice and morality. In Plato's Republic, Thrasymachus argued that justice was a tool of the powerful, while Callicles saw laws as a form of control by the weak over the strong. Both advocated for a more pragmatic and natural approach to political power.
- Gorgias distinguished himself through his radical skepticism and analysis of language. His three fundamental propositions questioned existence, knowledge, and communication. His view on the subjectivity of word meaning anticipated modern questions of semantics. Additionally, Gorgias advocated for Pan-Hellenism, seeking to unite the Greek city-states.
- Hippias, known for his vast encyclopedic knowledge, promoted progressive ideas for his time. He advocated for self-sufficiency and recognized universal human aspirations, transcending political divisions. As an itinerant educator, he encouraged a global and ethical perspective.
- Prodicus exemplified sophist skepticism, rejecting popular religion and criticizing materialism. He advocated for a life focused on intellectual and creative development, valuing the pursuit of excellence and independence.
Contributions and Influence
The sophists revolutionized Greek thought, especially in the art of rhetoric. They elevated oratory to an essential level in Athenian public debates and courts, transforming the practice of self-defense into a specialty. For these masters, rhetoric went beyond eloquence, encompassing grammar, literature, and logic, thus modernizing the educational system. Their contributions extended to physical sciences, astronomy, and mathematics, while also offering innovative interpretations of poetic works.
In social philosophy, the sophists introduced new perspectives on democracy, tyranny, and authoritarianism, centralizing these themes in philosophical debates. Although they prepared political leaders through specialized training, they didn't always aim for collective benefit. Unlike cosmologists, they focused on human beings and practical matters, encouraging discussions about ethics and the relativity of values, and stimulating critical reflection on social norms.
The influence of the sophists transcended philosophy, significantly impacting Greek literature and historiography. Historians like Thucydides offered scientific accounts of history, emphasizing the role of power in human relations. In dramaturgy, authors like Euripides frequently questioned the existence and nature of the gods, as exemplified in the tragedy Hippolytus. This approach broadened the scope of literary and historical analysis, introducing elements of skepticism and subjectivity.
In revitalizing philosophy, the sophists made it more practical and anthropocentric, directing debate toward ethical, social, and political issues. Their humanistic approach questioned the value of social institutions, laws, and progress. As educators, they transformed knowledge into something accessible and functional, stimulating debates about the relativity of moral standards and the complex relationships between means and ends in ethics.
Criticisms of Sophism
Despite their contributions, the sophists faced harsh criticism, especially from philosophers like Plato and Socrates. They were accused of corrupting philosophy by turning it into a commercial activity, selling their knowledge for money. This negative view portrayed them as manipulators who prioritized profit over truth and morality. Many considered them extreme relativists, claiming they defended ideas that favored power and personal advantage over solid ethical principles.
The popularity of the sophists among the Athenian elite also generated resentment. Their practical approach and innovative teaching method were viewed with suspicion by those who valued the disinterested pursuit of knowledge. Critics argued that by emphasizing persuasion and rhetoric, the sophists might be promoting the manipulation of the masses instead of genuine enlightenment.
Conclusion
The sophists revolutionized Greek philosophy, redirecting focus from metaphysical questions to human and social issues. Despite criticisms, their contributions to rhetoric, education, and political philosophy were significant. By questioning dogmas and adopting a practical approach to knowledge, they initiated debates that remain relevant, emphasizing the importance of critical thinking and social analysis in philosophical evolution.
Their impact on ancient Greek thought was transformative, challenging established beliefs and introducing questions that remain pertinent. The sophists' legacy extends beyond the criticisms of contemporaries like Plato, influencing modern philosophical movements such as utilitarianism, pragmatism, and existentialism. By centering human beings in their reflections, they shaped philosophy as a dynamic discipline, in constant dialogue with contemporary challenges. Their legacy persists as a testament to the importance of critical thinking and the search for practical solutions to human dilemmas.
References
- DUHOT, Jean-Jöel. Sócrates ou o despertar da consciência. São Paulo: Loyola, 2004.
- GRIMALDI, Nicolas. Sócrates, o feiticeiro. São Paulo: Loyola, 2006.
- GUTHRIE, W. K. C. Os sofistas. São Paulo: Paulus, 1995
- PLEBE, Armando. Breve história da retórica antiga. São Paulo: E. P. U e Edusp, 1978.
- ROMEYER-DHERBEY, G. Os sofistas. Lisboa: Edições 70, 1986.